PERSONAL EXPERIENCE
Before I get to numbers and stats and compare the challenge to Helium, I want to share something that was said to me about 10 articles back by the CM.
“Thank you for this and your many other well-written submissions. As always, we appreciate your use of personal experience, which gives your submissions a unique flavor. Keep up the great work. -”
I think you guys need to realize this. THIS is what AC is needing, wanting and looking for. It’s how they are setting themselves apart. When you finally read my articles that I put up for this challenge, you’ll see that nearly every one of them has “I” language, and I start the article with some personal story. This is something I do on my real account (an account where I’ve only received ONE rejection and it was in the new queue when the rules changed) and it’s something I did on this AC challenge account too.
Interestingly enough, Helium recently sent out an email stating that we should limit the use of ‘I’, ‘me’ and ‘we’ language, saying it was unprofessional. The two sites are wanting drastically different things. I know Suite101 wants third person for most of their stuff. Three sites, three requirements.
I received two rejections and requests for resubmit on this challenge. The first one was for a Call, or what’s not called an Assignment. I realize where I went wrong. The Assignment wanted to title of the album/song in the title, and I did not do that. They rejected the Assignment saying I did not follow the guidelines, but I was pretty sure my way was better… of course, I have years of experience at this and most of the CMs don’t, and most newbies don’t either.
TWO REJECTIONS – RESUBMITTED
Therefore, this article: Power Ballads of the ’80s was published for free, because I refused to change the title. It ended up being one of my triple digit page view articles, at a little under 200 as of today, and it will continually get decent page views, being sorta evergreen.
This article: How To Remove Earwax Safely, was also rejected. The reason for this was because I didn’t cite an sources. They specifically said that if this was from personal experience, I should state that in the article. They don’t mean to write: Source: Myself or to put at the end, “This article is from personal experience.”
What they mean is what I did. I went back and added this, “My son has had frequent ear infection as a child, so I have learned over the years, both from our pediatrician and personal experience, how to properly clean ears and remove earwax without damaging the ear.”
I put that very close to the beginning of the article (second full paragraph) and sent the exact same article in and got an offer. Again, personal experience is what they wanted. They truly mean it when they say they want information from the ‘source’. They want you to ‘write what you know’ from your personal experience with it.
~~~
INDEXING IS PROBLEMATIC
Let’s look at the cons going on right now. Currently, out of the 50 articles I have published on this profile, 8 of them are not currently indexed with Google. Of the ones that ARE indexed, only five of them are indexed with the pretty description instead of the ugly code. Those that did index on their own, usually did so within an hour of publishing or two. Those that did not index took well over a week or more to index, and ONLY indexed after a friend of mine posted them on her blog.
A new AC writer is not going to know about indexing. I kept track of the indexing situation and the ones that did not index show a MARKED decrease in page views compared to those that did. When I say marked, I mean the difference between 20-30 page views and over 150 page views. That might not seem like much, but we’re talking about four weeks only. Imagine if that were to stay the same over several months or a year?
People are being given upfront payment in part based on their previous performance of articles, so articles that aren’t performing well are hurting more than just performance bonuses, but they are hurting upfront offers too.
Please, I beg you, post every new article on an indexed blog or site to get it indexed as soon as possible. Drive traffic to your article immediately after it publishes so Google will pay attention to it. Us veterans on AC tell you newer/newbies that you don’t have to promote if you write properly for the web, and this is true if and only if Google actually picks up the articles in the first place!
However, comparing indexing to Helium, it’s important to know that usually only the first 3-5 ranked articles on Helium are going to get indexed by themselves unless you promote the content, so it’s not a huge issue for AC to make indexing part of the procedure (such as promoting being slightly required to get picked up) but AC should tell the writers on the site that this is the case, clearly in the FAQs with an explanation of how to check for indexing and what to do if you are not indexed. DO NOT submit to the Google Submit URL because this could hurt AC in the long run. That only needs the top level domain.
AC should continue to look further into the indexing situation, but a stop-gap measure would be to come forward and admit there is a problem and tell the members of the site what to do to fix it (ie: check for indexing, posting on other indexed sites, promoting, driving traffic, etc.) It will help new writers on the site realize they aren’t sucky writers after all; their content just couldn’t be found, and if they learn to promote properly to get indexed, it only benefits AC AND the writer too!
~~~~
WAIT TIME FOR APPROVALS
This is the single biggest CON to the entire AC experience. I love the upfront payments, I love the payment nearly every day, I love the bonus and the upfront and the options for different licenses and such. I DETEST the long wait times.
AC can tell me until they are blue in the face how it is better than print publications, but AC needs to realize they are NOT a print publication and they don’t pay ANYWHERE near what print pubs pay. WHEN AC starts offering steady two digit and three digit upfront payments on every article, I’ll wait a week or two. Until then, the wait shouldn’t be more than 24-72 hours, MAX. Anything more than that is very discouraging and it actually precipitates slowly writing and less articles.
It’s tough to load up a queue of articles, see a bunch of them sitting there unreviewed, and then continue writing more to stack up the queue. The natural tendency of human nature is to wait until a few clear out before writing more, and this is especially true of someone brand new to the site.
They got better toward the end though, and review times were 1-2 days on average. But boy, the beginning was rough. I waited nearly a week for the first Assignment (Call for Content) got reviewed!
I wrote 51 articles for the AC challenge, but only 50 were approved prior to the challenge closeing. For Helium, I wrote 65 for the challenge, and they were all published immediately.
~~~
PAYMENTS
The lowest payment I received were the freebies I put up – my choice. Of the ones I submitted for upfront payment, the lowest I received was two Assignments for $3.25. I knew that’s what they paid when I submitted them. The lowest ‘offer’ I got was:
Going Green on a Budget – $3.89
Thank you for this submission, Aimee. Unfortunately, due to the prevalence of content on AC on this topic, we cannot offer a higher Upfront Payment for this submission. As always, we encourage you to do a quick search of our content library before submitting content on popular topics such as this one so that you can create a more unique, niche-driven submission.
Like how they used my name there? Well, my fake name. I like that personal touch. After all, if they are going to ask us to be more personal, maybe they should be too. I do feel AC gave me decent communication through this, but I never emailed them for anything specific. I should have though, when they changed the title of this article: Preparing Your Home, and You, for Spring. Sorry CM, but that’s not the proper use of a reflexive personal pronoun. that wasn’t the title I submitted with. (Shrug)
My highest paying article was actually the How to Remove Earwax Safely, the one that I talked about above that was originally rejected. It received $5.16.
Two articles tied for second place at $5.11, and they were:
How to Train a Blue Heeler Puppy
How to Talk to Your Doctor About Alternative Therapy and Medicine
~~~
AVERAGES
My average payment ended up being: $3.52 per article if you include the free ones, and $4.77 if we don’t count the free ones.
My average page views right now are 77 per article. However, 5 of those articles were just published yesterday and have no views, so if I take them out, it bumps me up to 106 page views on average. That’s not too bad for the first full month. It should continue to rise.
HIGHS AND LOWS PAGE VIEWS
My highest page view article is 486 page views. The lowest that has page views is 7, published on the 6th and not indexed (When to get a second medical opinion) Most articles are between about 80-150, with a 20 on the one piece of poetry I put up just out of curiosity to see if poetry performed any better now than it did years ago. It doesn’t.
For a newbie, getting featured WORKS. Write content that is targetted to get featured. I had three pieces featured this first month – yes, three! and all three have much higher page views than those that weren’t featured.
HELIUM VS. AC MONEY
I think it’s important to note that the maximum one can make in upfront payment on Helium even if they have the max stars AND write to an empty title, is $3.50. And to get that, you must have five writing stars and write to an empty title. So on upfront payments, Associated Content SMOKES Helium.
However, on page view payments, for a new writer, Helium outshined AC. Unfortunately, I can’t do a fair comparison though. On AC, I earned almost $6 in performance bonus in the one month. On Helium, I earned about $23 bucks on performance bonus alone. Okay, but… and it’s a big but… I was doing the Helium challenge under my real name and posting links to things I wrote on my blog, on my forum and on other social networking sites to get the page views up to that point. On the AC challenge, I was not able to do that, because Aimee Berkley doesn’t exist on those site!
Helium ended with a total of $185.92 for 65 articles, and of those, one of them was a Marketplace article for $52.00.
AC ended with $182.16 for 50 articles, and none of them were special calls or assignments.
AND on Helium, I had to promote and rate articles to get to that amount, while on the AC challenge, I was in a vacuum and spent no time promoting or rating.
TIME SPENT VS DOLLAR MADE: HOURLY RATE
Helium’s hourly rate ended at: $2.46 per hour.
AC’s hourly rate ended at: $9.16
That’s not a typo. I actually, per hour spent, earned over $6.00 per hour more at AC than I did at Helium. AND that’s above minimum wage in every state of the US, and I did it all with my feet propped up in the recliner on my laptop. Now, that’s not that bad. And guess what? As you get better, your offers go up, and your performance bonus builds on itself and you get raises. Within a year, that could be significantly higher. I haven’t checked my hourly rate on my real account. That might be something I do before the end of my Suite101 challenge in May and see where it stands compared to this challenge account.
But it gets better. Guess what I can do now? I can take every one of these articles that I submitted to AC as non-exclusive and move them over to Helium in a month or so, and add another $1.50-3.00 to my wallet, as well as accruing the revenue and increasing my stars over there.
The two sites do tend to work well together for now.
SITE GLITCHES
The site glitches at AC are very frustrating. One morning I couldn’t get into the site and another evening I couldn’t get the pages to load at all. This slows down my time, and it does hit me at the bottom line. Helium only went down ONE time when I was doing my challenge with them, and it was a scheduled maintenance and was very early in the morning. The super slow page loads are hurting us not only in the amount of time we spend working on the site but also when the readers get too bored to wait for the pages to load and leave.
AC really needs to get a handle on the site maintenance. If it means a complete restart, that’s what they need to do. The site has been problematic every since I’ve been with them – it’s been in ‘beta’ mode for nearly four years or so now. That needs to stop. You can only hang your hat on beta mode for so long before someone who knows what they are doing gets in there and does it.
It’s better than it was… but it’s not good yet.
FINAL THOUGHTS
I submitted everything for free as DO and everything for upfront payment was submitted as non-exclusive, NO distribution, upfront payment.
- It appears the more articles you have pending in the queue on the same day, the lower the average of the offers are that day. On days I only had one or two articles, my offers were $5 or over, and days where there were three or four, I often got under $5. I’ve noticed on my real profile that this seems the case too. Three or more articles at once seems to lower the overall average. TIP: If you don’t publish many articles in a week, spread them out instead of submitting them all at once and see if your offers average higher. Doesn’t do much to help those who publish daily.
Promoting immediately after publishing helps drive traffic and will get articles indexed faster, most of the time. If you are going to promote, do it as soon as you can after publishing and your chances of getting indexed seem better.
- The only articles that got featured were ones with pictures. If you can find one quickly on Stock Exchange, do so, but don’t spend a huge time on pictures. If it takes you more than three minutes to find and upload a picture, you’ve wasted more time than having a picture will bring you in page views. REMEMBER: most visitors will come to your writing from search engines and won’t even see the picture until they get
to the article itself. It won’t entice anyone but maybe AC members to click on your articles.
Look at the Google Hot Searches/Top Searches and find ones that can be both hot searches and evergreen. For example, my article on Just Like Sugar received about 200 page views in this challenge, and it was a hot search, but it should be evergreen too. Unfortunately, AC removed the trademark symbol on that one. I wasn’t happy about that. They removed it about three days after it published. (Shrug)
- Get links to your profile out everywhere. Your profile links to your articles directly. Even if the Google spiders go out on AC, they might not get your articles if you don’t get links in to your profile that it indexes regularly. Everywhere you go on the internet that you can without spamming, get your AC Profile link up on those sites and then you will increase your page rank. It’s best not to change your name, because even though the incoming links will still get to your page, the page rank will drop!
I received targeted calls that were based on my niche – food and health – although the calls were for less than what AC was paying me upfront already, so I saw no reason to claim them. I did, however, get a targeted $10 partner call two or three days ago. Because of the challenge, I did not think it was right to accept it, but it goes to show that if you niche your writing or at the very least, make your niche more obvious than other writing, partner calls can come in as early as one month into it.
- I don’t see the purpose of the Assignment desk for general writers. There was nothing that paid much there, or anything that paid more than I was already getting, and almost all of the Assignments were free performance only articles. Also, the Assignments were really pushed in my face, so that a newbie might not even realize they can write on other topics in the beginning. That might need more clarification for some newbs.
Comment on other articles. I’m not saying to go out of your way to read more than you usually do, but if you do read an article, comment on it. Almost every single article Aimee commented on resulted in someone coming to an article of mine, and I’d say MOST of those people came back to read more. Having a following on AC helps page views. I can say this with definitive proof.
EVERY article I publish on my real account right now gets 300-700 hits within the first 1-2 days. It is you amazingly wonderful people on AC that do that for me. I don’t start getting search engines traffic until three or five days after publication. The first surge or page views I get is from my 640 fans and friends on AC. Build up a readership, a good base, that will give you a solid following. It’s amazing the difference that can make.
Doing this challenge showed me just how much every one of you mean to me… I missed the comments from the familiar faces. I missed the emails saying I had a comment. I like getting those emails. I do NOT like working in a vacuum, so for me, it is YOU GUYS who make AC the great place that it is. The money part is all secondary at this point. So thank you to all of you for that.
LASTLY and IMPORTANTLY
I’d like to give a nod to the first person to find me and realize that Aimee Berkley was really Michy. Rissa Watkins was the very first person to send me a private message and she knew it was me, because she says you can’t miss Michy’s style. What a nice compliment. Give her some page view love.
After her, the following AC members found my profile and commented on it regularly:
Momie Tullottes
K. Karl
You two ladies kept me sane through this challenge, because I knew, even though you weren’t sure it was me or not, you would at least comment. Your comments through the challenge were very uplifting to me. If you do the same to other newbies on the site, I can tell you right now, it makes a difference. Thank you both for that.
Also, I’m pretty sure the following people found me and knew it was me, or at least suspected:
Sophie emailed to welcome me and was super sweet.
CC Allison noticed me when one of my articles was featured, and she wrote to congratulate me! Thanks Allison!
Kristy Martz-Burmeister left a few comments for me, and they were thoughtful comments, not just smilies or marks.
Unwirklich Vin Zant came by a few times and commented too, after I was featured.
And of course, thanks to EMohrman and theBarefoot for keeping my secret. They both knew who I was, though Randy only commented on one things, and E, well, he’s got too much ego to actually lower himself to comment! Ha!
Did I miss anyone? If I did, I sincerely apologize and if you’ll comment here, when I do my next update, I’ll recognize you and link to your page!
Okay, does anyone have questions? Ask them here or pop by the thread on the AC forum and ask them there. I’d love to answer them if I missed anything.
I start the Suite101 month-long challenge in May and we’ll go until the end of May and see how they differ, and then I’ll be able to write up a full report on all three sites and tell you which is the best bet.
Right now, AC is the best bet for people with a little SEO experience, who want to build up some residual passive income while making a part-time active income web writing from personal experience.
Helium is good for new writers who are still perfecting their craft and learning keywords, to get experience, published fast and easy – OR – for those looking to squeeze a few more pennies out of their nonexclusive content, or to write for the marketplace (Yes, I’ll address the question I got about the marketplace in another blog next week.)
All right… moving on… questions? Comments?
Love and stuff,
Michy
BTW: Aimee Berkley is the name of the lead character in my newest break out novel called Eat it Up. The picture, however, is a picture of my beautiful daughter!
=================================================================